RAIPUR: Holding an insurance company guilty of deficiency in service and unfair trade practices, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Additional Bench, Raipur, has directed the insurer to pay a death insurance claim of Rs 1 crore to a woman whose husband died of cardiac arrest in Dec, 2019.
The commission held that the insurance company's failure to honour the death claim , despite the policy being in force and the death having occurred during its validity, amounted to deficiency in service and unfair trade practice.
The commission, comprising president Prashant Kundu and member Dr Anand Vergese, passed the order on Nov 3, while allowing a complaint filed by Chanda Pincha against Aditya Birla Sun Life Insurance Company Limited.
Apart from the Rs 1 crore insurance amount, the commission directed the company to pay Rs 1 lakh as compensation for mental and physical agony suffered by the complainant and Rs 15,000 towards litigation expenses. The entire amount has to be paid within 45 days. In case of failure to comply with the order within the stipulated period, the insurer will also have to pay interest at 7% per annum until payment.
According to the complaint, Chanda's husband, Pawan Pincha, a director of a private company, had purchased a policy, bearing number 007644841, on Sept 10, 2018. The policy provided a death cover of Rs 1 crore for the primary insured, Pawan, while his wife was the secondary insured with a cover of Rs 50 lakh.
The policy had a tenure of 39 years, with maturity scheduled for Sept 10, 2057. The complainant's husband had paid a premium of Rs 36,969.40.
Pawan died of a sudden cardiac arrest on Dec 21, 2019. Following his death, his wife, being the nominee, submitted a claim for the assured amount of Rs 1 crore. However, the insurance company rejected the claim on March 17, 2020, alleging that the deceased had failed to disclose several other life insurance policies taken from different insurance companies.
The insurer maintained that the deceased had obtained multiple life insurance policies, including policies with substantial sums assured, without disclosing the relevant details in the proposal form. It argued that the suppression of material information amounted to a violation of the insurance contract and justified repudiation of the claim.
The company also challenged the maintainability of the complaint, contending that the commission lacked territorial and pecuniary jurisdiction. It further alleged that the complainant had not impleaded the concerned insurance agent as a party to the proceedings.
However, the commission, after examining the complaint, affidavits, insurance documents, medical records and correspondence between the parties, rejected the insurer's objections.
The commission observed that the insurer had issued the policy after receiving the proposal and premium, and had an opportunity to examine the deceased's existing insurance coverage before accepting the proposal. It noted that the deceased had held other life insurance policies, but the insurer had failed to establish that the complainant was responsible for any concealment or that the circumstances justified repudiating the death claim.
The order also referred to the fact that claims under certain other insurance policies held by the deceased had been settled by the respective insurance companies, while the claim under the disputed policy was rejected.
It consequently directed the company to release the Rs 1 crore death benefit to the complainant, along with compensation and litigation expenses, within 45 days.
Contact to : xlf550402@gmail.com
Copyright © boyuanhulian 2020 - 2023. All Right Reserved.